Popular Posts

Sunday, May 27, 2012

My book selected to go to the Frankfurt Book Fair - the world's largest!

      I am still recovering from the shock of having my book selected to go on the New Zealand stand at the Frankfurt Book Fair.  The New Zealand Society of Authors, to which I belong, is showcasing 40 New Zealand books at Frankfurt, the world's largest book fair. Supported by generous sponsorship from Copyright Licensing Limited, the stand takes advantage of New Zealand's status of Guest of Honor at the 2012 Fair.
      This is a great thrill and the Society is already giving the 40 authors excellent advice about promoting our books to the publishers from all over the world who will be attending - I'm reliably informed the headcount of publishing firms is 20,000!
      Preparing information about my book is helping me focus more and more on who needs to use it, why they need to and how it will benefit them. Very helpful. The book itself is for environmental experts in the public, private and not-for-profit sectors who find themselves involved with training.
      Trainers call these invaluable people "subject matter experts" or SMEs - not to be confused with Small-Medium Enterprises, another common meaning for "SME"...  Many environmental subject matter experts have specialized knowledge gained from their experience, rather than from a formal qualification. Their skill and enthusiasm means they can make very good trainers, and the advice in my book, based on my 20 years of experience with environmental training programs, helps them access and apply new knowledge from the world of professional training. It's a winning combination that can really lift the environmental performance of a wide range of business activities.
      As well as marketing my "7 Steps" book to real live publishers, I aim to have a near-complete manuscript of a further book and a list of other books I'm keen to write about different aspects of the business benefits of good environmental performance. I'm most definitely more than a one-hit wonder - though turning my first book into that first hit is my immediate goal!

    Click on these key words to find out more the Frankfurt Book Fair, New Zealand as the 2012 Guest of Honour, the New Zealand Society of Authors, Copyright Licensing Limited - and, of course - my book, "Seven Steps to successful environmental training programs".

Saturday, May 5, 2012

E-training for contractors


      Some years ago, a major New Zealand water utility company wanted its contractors to prepare environmental management plans. 
      The company was conscious that how it installed, operated and maintained its city’s water, stormwater and wastewater services had the potential to affect the natural environment during the regular upgrades, maintenance and repairs that all such large networks need. It decided to actively seek environmentally sound solutions that complied with law and regulations, and to go beyond ‘compliance as a minimum’ by aiming for best environmental practice. This meant working closely with the contractors who carried out the work on its behalf.
      Given that its contractors build, operate and maintain lifeline water services that support healthy communities, the company believed that its contractors needed formal systems to avoid or minimize environmental damage every bit as much as they needed financial, health and safety, quality and traffic management systems.        
      Accordingly, it decided to require all its contractors to prepare environmental management plans, or EMPs. These plans would help them manage their activities and associated environmental risks, staff responsibilities and communication so as to avoid or minimize potential impacts of their activities and to help maintain and improve the environment. It also provided a framework for both the contractors and the utility itself to monitor their environmental performance.  
      To be eligible to bid for work with the utility, every contractor was required to prepare a company environmental management plan every year. Some large or very environmentally risky projects also needed a specific project environmental management plan.  
      However, many of the contractors were very small firms, some of them ‘one-man bands’, such as concrete cutters who carry out their work from a tradesman’s van. It would have placed a big burden on these suppliers make them write an EMP without giving them any help. Other contractors were big companies who either had existing plans or were well able to prepare their own plans, but the utility didn’t want them all taking different approaches, because it would be too difficult to assess the resulting variety of plans. The company also wanted to create a ‘level playing’ field, providing equal opportunities for all its contractors, regardless of  their size or capabilities. 
      To ensure a consistently high standard of environmental management plan, the company provided a budget and support package to outline a minimum acceptable standard of environmental protection measures and control procedures. The aim was to help contractors reduce the environmental risks of all their day-to-day operations, thereby reducing the potential for environmental non-compliance from works being completed by contractors on the utility’s behalf. 
      The support package provided a Guide to preparing an environmental management plan and a corresponding Template into which the contractors could start writing their plan. The Guide set out a straightforward project planning process to identify environmental risks and the management strategies to reduce them. This process helped the contractors to:
  • prepare detailed plans for using best environmental management practices 
  • comply with the conditions of project approvals 
  • comply with general environmental legislation and regulations 
  • minimize environmental risk 
  • avoid and minimize adverse environmental effects of works 
  • monitor activities and effects 
  • take action to mitigate or remedy any adverse environmental effects; and, if necessary, to change the way they do things to prevent any recurrence 
  • continually improve their environmental performance.
      Also in the support package was an interactive toolbox containing:
  • a leaflet summarizing the package 
  • a background document explaining the environmental management plan framework and the reasons for setting it up, as well as the objectives and scope of a plan 
  • an electronic plan template with all the headings set out and some helpful information already provided 
  • printed workbooks containing background information and examples to help contractors fill out the template for their organization 
  • a set of environmental control procedures (also known as environmental management procedures or standard work practices or operating procedures) and other resources prepared for the contractors to use and adapt for their plans and their site management and monitoring processes 
  • a self-paced interactive online learning program, supported by classroom-based training 
  • ongoing support from staff of the utility.
      The first plans were uniformly excellent – a result that could not have been achieved cost-effectively in any other way.
      Regular site inspections then made sure the contractors were supported in following and, if necessary, reviewing their plans.  
      An interesting finding from the process was that having such plans was invaluable when these contractors were bidding for other work, especially council or government projects: it gave them good non-price attributes and a great track record.   
      There were other benefits of contractors developing and implementing their environmental management plans.
      For both the utility company and the contractors, these included a clear understanding of how the utility and the contractors would act as one team to comply with legal requirements, avoid environmental impacts and achieve best practice in environmental performance, and an accepted agreement on environmental best practice before works start. 
      Other benefits for the contractors were a reduced risk of budget overruns due to unanticipated environmental problems and a head start in terms of non-price attributes when competing for other contracts. 
      Other benefits for the utility company were confidence that its contractors had planned and identified how to complete works in an environmentally responsible manner and the development of a tool to more accurately measure the time and effort taken to address environmental issues and practices. 
      And of course, other stakeholders and the wider community could have confidence that the utility’s works were not only timely and cost-effective, but planned and carried out in accordance with sound environmental practice. 
      All in all, the environmental management plan program resulted in a step-change in industry capacity and capability. It provided contractors large and small with new and enhanced skills that offer both business and environmental benefits that will continue to grow over time.  
      Michael Lindgreen was the project sponsor. Now with Andrew.Stewart Limited, he says that ‘to achieve the corporate goal of a consistent level of environmental best practice we recognised that we needed to do things differently. We wanted to challenge the industry norm of simply prescribing our environmental requirements and standards and then expecting contractors to meet them. Instead, we opted to go down the path of engagement and partnership to build industry capacity and change behaviors over time.’   
      He is convinced it was this ‘one-team’ approach that produced their industry-leading environmental management support package – a toolkit developed specifically for contractors to understand environmental risk, risk management strategies and how to develop and implement effective documented management systems. 
      Support was crucial, says Michael. ‘Following the implementation of the system and the requirement for all contractors to develop environmental management plans, we further supported our contractors through tool-box talks, industry presentations, a ‘help-line’ email address and free staff advice when required. The final, and perhaps the most important step, of “bringing the plans to life” through effective implementation was further supported through on the ground monitoring, advice and education.’ 
      With a concerted effort and, importantly, buy-in from all levels – from senior management to the digger driver – Michael says the organization saw ‘the quantifiable number of environmental incidents drop significantly, while the intangibles of improved industry reputation, contractor buy-in, client – contractor relationships and demonstrated industry best practice increased dramatically.’ 
      Find out more about Michael's company here.

Monday, February 20, 2012

E- and m-training: glimpsing the future in what we're doing now

     After four failed attempts to build a grassed swale along a motorway to the design and performance specifications, an environmental manager told me she finally got the project engineer to agree that maybe the topsoil had to be sieved after all, and that perhaps it was indeed a good idea to mark out the dimensions for the digger driver to follow. 
      Roadside swales are notoriously difficult to build for long term operation and trouble-free maintenance. Fifth time lucky, she got what she wanted – a swale that was properly shaped, compacted, topsoiled and planted – and that didn’t come apart in the rain!
      I suggested to her that next time the now-expert team built a swale, she could stand nearby, with a colleague filming everything on video while she explained exactly what they were doing, how they were doing it and why it had to be done that way (noisy machinery may necessitate doing a voice-over later on). Even better to get the operators and other people actually doing the job to explain how they do their work. Then I suggested this video go on the company’s intranet as part of their training and quality procedures so that this knowledge can be easily passed on to others.
      This reminded me of the operations manager of a major utility company who decided that with the imminent retirement of a whole tranche of baby-boomers, he needed to film them talking about their routine procedures so they could pass on their skills to the very junior people succeeding them. He got them talking about anything and everything they could think of about the network and the different jobs they did to keep it in good shape. I loved the example he gave of one man describing the exact sound and vibration a valve makes as it's being properly bled - priceless value!
      E-learning and m-learning – electronic and mobile learning – are the way of the future. One e-training project I worked on was really quite astonishingly successful. No matter how interactive they are, such methods will never totally replace face-to-face training or, especially for practical work like environmental management, on-site practical learning. But they will increasingly be used to demonstrate on-the-job skills as part of gaining a qualification. 
      Consider this scenario, which I’ve adapted from a story recounted in 2005 at a meeting of the NZ Association of Training and Development by Elizabeth Valentine (now working with a major Industry Training Organisation): 

      A worker on a big construction site is doing his round of routine inspections of the erosion and sediment controls. He has a map-based checklist that he can tick off and comment on so he can document and report on what he finds. He also has a smartphone with a camera and the ability to access the as-built diagrams for every measure. He sees something wrong with a large control measure and dials up the as-built to check what it should look like. He takes a photo of the fault and uploads the image to an online register that records the measure’s name and location and the time and date of the photo. The upload alerts the environmental team that a repair is needed. The next device is smaller but also has a minor fault. This time, he photographs and uploads an image of the fault, then fixes it and uploads the image of the repaired and now fully functioning device. He also uploads the last two photos to his e-learning portfolio as part of gaining his work-related qualification.

      How cool is that!

Thursday, January 19, 2012

The quality of our projects depends on the quality of our relationships

      '"The quality of our projects depends on the quality of our relationships" - I learned this from Tangata Whenua,' said Green MP Catherine Delahunty yesterday at the New Zealand Association for Environmental Education (NZAEE) conference which I'm currently attending. (Tangata Whenua means the people of the land, the Maori people so strongly and positively associated with place in New Zealand.)
      What better way to sum up the theme of my book, Seven Steps to Successful Environmental Training Programs: partnership is, I firmly believe, at the heart of this success.
     The topic of my book touched a chord with lots of people, including some of the many overseas delegates attending this wonderful conference. One man told me how he works closely with a wide range of stakeholders when preparing and delivering his plant and animal pest control training programs - he'd never thought of how he worked as being "partnership" - but it undoubtedly is - and all the better for being how he naturally goes about his work. And having a conscious awareness that this is what he is doing could strengthen those relationships still more.
      Wait for a case study on his work soon....!
      Several people from local and overseas universities and polytechnics were present, and it is thrilling to see an emerging focus on adult vocational training as a positive force for environmental change as part of a new knowledge-based restoration economy.
      This year's NZAEE conference theme is "Changing course for a sustainable world" with the image of a mighty waka (canoe). The Association does wonderful work in early childhood, school and tertiary education, with strong input from local government, and I see training as being another powerful paddle for the sustainability waka.


      Over the next few weeks, I'll update this blog along a new series theme and we'll see where that journey takes us.
      There is a new short e-book on training available on my website (Environmental Training – how to change the world, one workshop at a time), and printed copies of the long book (Seven Steps to Successful Environmental Training Programs) in colour are now also for sale - click here to find out more. 
      Click here to find out more about the NZAEE and here to find out about this year's conference - there are similar associations in many other countries - here's the Australian one, for a start.      

Thursday, December 15, 2011

A huge thank-you to the Sustainability Society for launching my book!

      Last night the Sustainability Society launched two books about sustainability - my "Seven Steps to Successful Environmental Training Programs", and Niki Harre's "Psychology for a better world: Strategies to Inspire Sustainability". Niki is a social psychologist in the University of Auckland's Department of Psychology. 
      We had 5 minutes each to overview our books - and this was a real challenge: both of us are used to 50-minute speaking slots, and though I've had coaching on the "elevator speech" and 8-minute speaking slots, I must confess to being less than stellar with my five minutes! But as I'm a member of the Society, I knew many of the people there and they were very complimentary, bless them. The one thing I forgot to say at the end was how environmental training creates new professions, thereby building what Storm Cunningham calls the "restoration economy" from inside our faltering macro-economies.  You can find out more about this in an earlier blog.
      I love Niki's focus on the importance of positive mental states for sustainable behaviour change. This is something I've always firmly believed in, and based as she is at the University, Niki has been able to back up all her thinking with impressive amounts of research.
      What a wonderful opportunity this launch was - and it was the real thing: wine (and water and juice), elegant finger-food and an informed and interested audience - the Society really knows how to put on a good do. The networking afterwards was highly informative and I'll be chasing up a few people to gather up more case studies to disseminate via my website (fully acknowledged, of course!) on how different kinds of organizations (government agencies, businesses, utilities, not-for-profits) are delivering environmental training programs.
      Several friends and colleagues came along, one of whom changed an international flight to come back a day early so he could attend. Of course friends and professional peers are the most daunting audience for any speaker, but their interest and support was heart-warming. Thank you all.
      Wow! I feel I've been blooded as a "real" author! Many thanks to the Sustainability Society!


The Sustainability Society is a Learned Society of the Institution of Professional Engineers, and membership is open to everyone - you don't have to be an engineer to join (I'm not one) and the annual fee is very reasonable, with special student rates. Several times a year the Society runs free workshops on topics of note, as well as a sensational annual conference that draws outstanding speakers and audiences from all over the world. The 5th International Conference is at the University of Auckland from 27-30 November 2012 - check it out here.


Click here to find out about Niki's book. Click here to find out more about mine.


I'll be taking a break from this blog over Christmas-New Year and will resume sometime in January. Wishing you all the very best for your end-of-year break and a very happy and fulfilling year in 2012.

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Policy - an extra plank in your training platform

      Over the last five weeks, I’ve looked at 5 Ps that will make sure you develop and deliver sensational training:

  • Partnership
  • Personas
  • Performance
  • Process
  • Proof.

      As I start to think about my next professional speaking engagement on the topic, I’ve gone back to the seven steps I describe in the book and pulled out one more 'P' for you: Policy.

      Before you invest a lot of time for no return, it pays to ask a few hard questions. If you don't, be sure your manager and financial officer will do so, long before you get to put the proposition to your elected representatives, who will probably ask the toughest question of all!
      
Two questions need scoping out before you do anything about environmental training:
  • is training the solution to the problem? 
  • why should your organization do it? Can/should/will anyone else do it instead? 
      To answer the first question; training won’t solve your problem if you can’t define the environmental Performance gap in terms of what actions people need to change or acquire: trainees must have a clear definition of what they need to do.  

      To answer the second: there are several reasons why public agencies can justify running or supporting environmental training programs. The most common is that the required training is not available elsewhere: issue- or locality-specific performance needs are often not addressed in formal qualifications or by other training providers, so over time public agency staff build up expertise not often found anywhere else. 

      Of course, the issue must fall broadly within the legal mandate of the environmental agency and there must be a demonstrable cause-and-effect link between the environmental issues observed and outcomes desired and the identifiable performance issues in the relevant sector.

      Equally obviously, large organizations and utilities can set up their own in-house training, and such initiatives can be very effective.

      Sources of data and evidence for your initial research that can justify setting up a training program (as well as monitoring its ongoing effectiveness) can include things like: 
  • state of the environment monitoring indicating an emerging or intensifying problem
  • monitoring of environmental permits indicating poor compliance with conditions 
  • high use of enforcement compared with other methods of promoting good performance 
  • reviews of the effectiveness of plans, policies, regulations and enforcement that indicate different methods need to be used to achieve desired outcomes 
  • public complaints or concerns about the issue and/or its current management 
  • introduction of new legislation, policies, strategies or guidelines that change the performance benchmark 
  • industry requests for assistance 
  • evidence from other jurisdictions about the cost-effectiveness of training. 
      The other parts of the policy framework include: 
  • the creation of a new technical guideline or adaptation of someone else’s to help those in the sector of interest use effective environmental control measures 
  • regulatory procedures to ensure that they obtain environmental approvals that require the control measures to be used. 
      In my experience, it is desirable for public agencies delivering environmental training to have some leverage over the relevant sector, whether via legal approvals and/or enforcement or other methods such as financial penalties or incentives and so on, to make a good case for their attending the training.

      These 6 Ps will help you build a compelling case for the need for your training program. I wish you all the best with it!


This information comes from various parts of my book ‘Seven Steps to Successful Environmental Training’. 

Tuesday, November 29, 2011

Proof: how will you make sure your trainees are meeting their performance standard?

      It’s always important for trainers to know their training is effective, and there is a growing focus on the different levels of evaluation, from the “smile sheets” we give out at the end of a workshop to a full financial return on investment - and beyond!
      For environmental trainers, there is often an additional impetus, which is the need for compliance monitoring to ensure that organizations are meeting their legal obligations under environmental laws. Many are required to monitor their own compliance with various operating permits, and environmental regulators often have pollution hotlines or well-publicized phone numbers for the public to report matters of interest from smoky vehicle exhausts to over-use of water. Some also have formal systems for regular inspections of activities of particular concern.
      Effective environmental training is only one part of a wider environmental training program and such programs need to be set up so that their outcomes and effectiveness can be evaluated. This needs to be done right from the very beginning of any program. Likewise, the level of compliance with your environmental performance standards or guidelines will be part of your assessment of the effectiveness of your training. 
      A number of people in the training profession have identified seven levels of evaluation of the effectiveness of training. Levels 1-4 are from Donald Kirkpatrick, Level 5 is from Jack Philips and Levels 6 and 7 are from Alastair Rylatt – the sources are listed below. The seven levels are:
  • Level 1 – Reaction: Did they like it? 
  • Level 2 – Learning: What did they learn from it? 
  • Level 3 – Performance: What can they do as a result of it? 
  • Level 4 – Results: Was the training worthwhile? 
  • Level 5 – ROI: Did it produce a financial return on investment? 
  • Level 6 – Sustainability: has it become ‘how we do things around here’? 
  • Level 7 – Sharing the benefit: how is this helping others and the planet? 
      So there are two layers of “proof” or evaluation: effectiveness of your training; and effectiveness of the wider environmental management program to which your training contributes. 
      Regular site inspections will give you good information for both - and in many jurisdictions, the costs of these inspections can be recovered from the organization holding the relevant environmental permits. From an environmental regulator's point of view, this is good news: the funding doesn’t come out of rates!
      How does this analysis work if you are a corporate or not-for-profit interested in environmental training? How does it work if you are an environmental regulator?

This blog is the last in my series of Top Five Tips for people starting to think about setting up or expanding an environmental training program. The other four were on Partnership, Personas, Performance and Process.


What’s your hot topic for environmental training? Contact me here or make a comment below and I’d be delighted to respond with some thoughts.
The information in this blog is drawn from comes from Chapter 6 and part of Chapter 8.3 of my book ‘Seven Steps to Successful Environmental Training’. Thanks again to the New Zealand Association of Training and Development, from which I’ve learned so much about training evaluation; and as always to Ann Andrews for encouraging me to disseminate this material more widely.
The three sources of the seven levels of evaluation are (1) Kirkpatrick, Donald, 1998, Evaluating Training Programs: the Four Levels. Berrett-Koehler Publishers Inc. San Francisco; (2) Philips, Dr Jack, 1997, Return on Investment in Training and Performance Improvement Programs. Butterworth Heinemann; and (3) Rylatt, Alastair, 2003, Beyond ROI – seven levels of evaluation. An article in People and Performance, the magazine of the New Zealand Association of Training and Development, June 2003.